• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Pizza and Shakes

At Pizza and Shakes, we celebrate the art of pizza-making with a unique twist. Nestled in the heart of New York City, our establishment offers an inviting atmosphere perfect for any occasion, from a quick bite to a cozy dinner date. Our menu features customizable, made-to-order pizzas bursting with fresh ingredients and innovative sauces. Paired with our indulgent ice cream and gelato shakes, each visit becomes a delightful experience. Customers rave about our friendly service and spacious, accessible seating options. Join us at 209 W 57th St for a taste of culinary creativity where pizza and shakes come together in perfect harmony.

Pizza and Shakes: Reviews & Ratings

ElBachir C.
ElBachir C.

Smooth experience from ordering to eating. Food: the portion is big enough to fill you, so make sure to come with an empty stomach. I did go with make your own pizza, which is something unusual for a food place. (Spicy tomato sauce as a base, Chicken, olives, mushroom) and I sauce it up at the end when it comes out from the oven. (Check picture) Ambiance: very quiet and chill, clean, and convenient Service: great with fast process and friendly process I will be back for sure

Frank G.
Frank G.

Had a date night with the wifey and found we were hungry for something quick and easy, yet delicious, and we happened upon Pizza and Shakes! Sooo glad we did! Pizza made to order with all the toppings you want; it was delicious! And the staff were courteous and quick too! So coming back here!

Chris S.
Chris S.

Came by after seeing a Broadway show on Wednesday night. A few people but pretty empty so we got to order right away. It's like long/ovular personal pizzas with the option to make your own. We got the Overload and Kansas BBQ. The guy also let us customize the sauces on them. They were soooo yummy - excellent toppings and sauces. They are also made fresh to order. Two pizzas were perfect for two people, it not a little much. They also have gelato right there for a nice dessert afterward. Seating is bar style along the walls. Lots of napkins and hand sanitizer around. Also very well-lit and comfortable. Definitely a great find.

S. Anne T.
S. Anne T.

So we ordered the taylor BOGO offer and sadly it did not hit the same way as our original order below. I don't think it was bad per se, but it felt like someone else was making it because the first time was just so perfect. I'd still try it again, with hopes it's better and consistent.

Melanie N.
Melanie N.

This place is delicious. I had the quatreto pizza and tiramisu shake. The pizza was delicious and had a crispy crust flavor wise was just amazing! The shake could use a little help but it was decent.

Cristina C.
Cristina C.

My friend and I were in the area and stumbled upon this place cause there was a BOGO free deal on UberEats. We ordered the quatreto pizza to share and it was really good! This was basically a flatbread pizza and the bread was so good. All the cheeses and sauces complimented each other so well. They were also giving out samples of their siena sandwich and that was delicious! The mozzarella was so soft and fresh and the pesto was one of the top pestos I have ever had. It tasted really fresh and authentic. The restaurant had a couple of seatings along the wall and the place was very clean! The workers were really nice too. If I'm ever in the area, I'll definitely stop by again. Their gelatos also looked really good too!

Shanita M.
Shanita M.

My broke BFF ( daughter) really wanted pizza, and this was the place I happened to be walking past. I originally went in with the intention of buying two slices. However, that was not an option. They serve oval flatbread pies. I got one pizza to share with my daughter. We did a build your own pie. My pizza maker was very generous with the toppings and cheese. The pizza itself was better than I expected. It was really good and tasted fresh. In addition to the price being extremely affordable. Apart from pizza, they sell gelato and make shakes. Before my daughter decided on which flavor Gelato she wanted, the server allowed her to sample a few. I will say it is not NYC pizza yet good pizza....establishment is very clean.....affordable....and staff were friendly. When in the area, of course, I will stop by for another pie.

Deshika B.
Deshika B.

If I could give this place 20 stars, I would! The pizza is out of this world amazing and it came out piping hot, tasted delicious, and all the ingredients were so fresh. The cool thing about this place and I'm seeing a trend at a lot of restaurants is that you don't have to order at the register you can just go up to a monitor and you can order their premade pizzas, which I did. I got the #12 Kansas, or you can make your own pizza with all the toppings that you want, or don't want. You can choose a different crust, flavored sauces, different cheeses; there are so many varieties! tTe best thing about this place is the price point. Y'all, my pizza was about $12. I also got the Parmesan garlic twists which was to die for! Super delicious and the Parmesan was caked on. I'm obsessed with cheese so no complaints for me! I literally can't wait to visit this place again!

Location

Welcome to Pizza and Shakes, a delightful culinary destination nestled in the heart of New York City at 209 W 57th St. This vibrant eatery specializes in mouthwatering pizzas and delectable shakes, offering an inviting atmosphere that caters to everyone—from families to couples enjoying a night out. With easy accessibility features and an extensive menu, Pizza and Shakes aims to deliver an unforgettable dining experience.

At Pizza and Shakes, the focus is on personalization and quality. Customers can indulge in make-your-own pizzas, featuring a wide array of toppings, sauces, and fresh ingredients. The option to customize allows for a unique culinary adventure with each visit. Whether you choose a classic flavor or venture into bold combinations, like Spicy Tomato Sauce with chicken and olives, the pizza is crafted to satisfy.

The ambiance here is both relaxed and chic. Many patrons describe it as a quiet retreat, perfect for enjoying a casual meal or post-Broadway show snack. With options for outdoor seating and private dining, it’s versatile enough for any occasion. Guests have highlighted the pleasant interactions with staff and the quick service, ensuring satisfaction from the moment you enter.

In addition to their pizzas, Pizza and Shakes offers an enticing selection of gelato shakes. Choices range from the classic Vanilla Shake to indulgent options like the Tiramisu and Hazelnut shakes, all available for $9.25. Each shake is designed to be a satisfying finish to your meal, providing a creamy, sweet treat that perfectly complements the savory pizzas.

  • Location and Accessibility: 209 W 57th St, NYC, with wheelchair access and takeout options.
  • Service Highlights: Fast, friendly waitstaff, along with happy hour specials for added value.
  • Ambiance: Comfortable seating with cleanliness and good lighting, suited for both casual and special dining.

The reviews echo a common theme: satisfaction with generous portions and the quality of food. Customers have raved about the unique twist they bring to the pizza experience, where personalization reigns supreme. Despite the occasional inconsistency in dishes, loyal patrons are eager to return, fueled by the promise of hearty meals and delightful shakes.

Whether you’re stopping by for a quick bite or planning a special evening, Pizza and Shakes is poised to deliver on flavor and experience. Don’t miss the chance to explore their culinary delights and enjoy everything this gem in New York has to offer.